The Competition and Markets Authority's investigation into the "interconnected web" of AI companies led to the conclusion.
The UK's Competition and Markets Authority has concluded its examination of Microsoft and Inflection AI's relationship and found no evidence to support any anti-competitive allegations.
It did, however, declare it to be a "relevant merger situation" under its purview, meaning that comparable transactions that don't precisely fit the requirements of an acquisition might be looked into in the future.
Mustafa Suleyman and Karén Simonyan, the co-founders of Inflection AI, joined Microsoft in March, bringing with them "several" colleagues. Among them was Jordan Hoffman, who is currently in charge of Microsoft's AI Hub in London.
On July 16, the CMA launched an investigation into whether these and Microsoft's other agreements with Inflection could be viewed as anti-competitive.
A summary of the CMA's inquiry, including its conclusion, was made public. In the end, the merger in the domains of consumer chatbots and fundamental AI models "does not give rise to a realistic prospect of a substantial lessening of competition as a result of horizontal unilateral effects."
Why Was The CMA Interested In Microsoft's Hire From Inflection?
The investigation looked at "whether it is or may be the case that Microsoft Corporation has created a relevant merger situation as a result of its hiring of certain former employees of Inflection and its entry into associated arrangements with Inflection," according to the CMA.
The staff members in charge of AI development are "at the core of any business seeking to develop FMs or chatbots," according to the summary released this week, since "any technology in this space can quickly become obsolete without ongoing development."
"Given this situation, the CMA believes that obtaining a group with pertinent expertise — even in the absence of additional assets — could potentially come under its purview for merger control," the CMA stated.
The nonexclusive licensing agreement to use Inflection's intellectual property for Microsoft's Azure cloud is one of the "associated arrangements" to which it alludes. Reuters reports that Microsoft spent $650 million for the Inflection team and this privilege.
Microsoft-Inflection might result in a “substantial lessening of competition within any market or markets in the United Kingdom for goods or services,” according to the CMA, putting the body in charge if the merger was approved.
"We are confident that the hiring of talent promotes competition and should not be treated as a merger," a Microsoft representative said in a statement to the BBC in July.
Why The Collaboration Was Approved By The CMA?
In addition to creating its own generative AI chatbot, Pi, Inflection intends to provide a basic AI model for business clients. This implies that the competition in the consumer chatbot and fundamental AI model domains may be disproportionately threatened by its cooperation with Microsoft.
Nevertheless, it absolved the partnership of competition concerns in both of these markets, even after employing the "vast majority of [Inflection's] team" and making arrangements that the CMA saw as a merger.
In terms of the chatbot market, the CMA approved the merger for the following reasons:
Before partnering with Microsoft, Inflection's share of chatbot domain visits in the United Kingdom was quite tiny, and unlike its competitors, it had not been able to significantly grow or maintain its user base.
Pi does not significantly hinder Microsoft's or its rivals' chatbots in terms of competitiveness.
It is not a significant source of product innovation to allow for unfair competition restrictions in the now or the future. Competitors might be able to duplicate many of its best characteristics.
Inflection would have had a difficult time competing for clients and achieving its goals for development.
For the following reasons, it approved the merger in the UK's pioneering AI market:
The enterprise AI model from Inflection was not able to be differentiated from competitors by any of its prospective clients.
It is already possible for rivals without commercial AI models to convert their current consumer solutions into enterprise equivalents.
Why Is The CMA looking Into Large IT companies?
To get an early advantage and profit from the AI boom, large IT companies are making fast investments in fledgling AI startups. Notably, collaborations between NVIDIA and Inflection AI, Microsoft and OpenAI, and Google and Anthropic demonstrate this.
These partnerships, however, have the potential to create market dominance, which makes it harder for smaller, independent businesses to get capital, draw in talent, or match the large players' sophisticated technology and reach.
Complete mergers and acquisitions can cause delays or even stop procedures because they frequently result in intense regulatory scrutiny and possible antitrust actions. Big Tech steers clear of this predicament by strategically investing in the most promising companies and/or hiring their best employees, giving them unfettered access to cutting-edge technologies and increasing their influence.
The CMA is still looking into the "interconnected web" of artificial intelligence businesses.
The complex web of interactions between AI players is highlighted by the probe into Microsoft and Inflection. After working at Google DeepMind, Suleyman and Karén Simonyan co-founded Inflection. (Simoyan moved to work under Suleyman as chief scientist at Microsoft AI.)
Pi is a generative AI chatbot created by Inflection AI that aims to be a "kind and supportive companion." The extensive language model that powers Pi, Inflection 2.5, is hosted on Microsoft Azure by it.
When Inflection AI was brought up in a request for comments on "AI partnerships and other arrangements," the CMA became interested in the company in April. The CMA specifically emphasized a number of connections between major IT firms and AI startups:
Microsoft and Mistral AI, despite the alliance wasn't eligible for further examination due to Mistral's significant investment.
As of August 8, the probe between Amazon and Anthropic has been elevated to a full investigation.
Inflection AI And Microsoft
The CMA has also been investigating Google's affiliation with Anthropic and OpenAI. In April, the CMA stated that close ties amongst AI industry participants "may be aggravating existing positions of market power through the FMs [foundation models] value chain."
The authority claims that there is "an interconnected web of over 90 partnerships and strategic investments involving the same firms" in the AI industry.